Are Testimonials Factual Information or Creative Advertising?
It seems everywhere you go there is a glowing testimonial about the product or service you are checking out. They state that it works so well that everyone needs it.
BUT, is this a REAL testimonial or just creative advertising?
Many of these testimonials read like they are too good to be true. They could be very accurate but, because of how they are constructed, the testimonial reads like more hype than reality. Rather than simply stating how the product or service did what was advertised, the testimonial gives an almost unbelievable account of results. In many cases this causes the testimonial to backfire on its effect.
So, how did the testimonial go from effective to hype?
Like everything else in the world, there is a creeping change that occurred. Gradually people changed the context of the testimonial to be more like an ad than that of the original testimonial. Once these revised testimonials got to the market, and people realized that the context had changed, they became less effective.
If you are writing a testimonial but constructing it like an ad, there is a high probability that it will not work. You can’t hide an ad, regardless of the context, under the guise of something else. Today’s market has seen almost every type advertising that you can present. They understand when marketers are using a form of communication that does not fit the original meaning. As the saying goes, you can fool some of the people some of the time….
What is a true testimonial and how can you identify one?
A functional testimonial has several very significant differences from a sales ad. For instance, the testimonial will usually state the results of using the product or service rather than the benefits of trying the product or service. A true testimonial will be written in the first person context rather than the third person. It will use I or me in describing the person using the product or service. Typically it will be three or four sentences long.
By contrast, a testimonial as an ad will be longer in length. Some are several paragraphs long. My experience of testimonials is that they are very seldom that long. Most people just won’t write that much. Most testimonials are also worded with conversation words versus sales type words. They are worded as if you are telling a friend about your experience rather than if you are trying to convince a friend to use the product or service.
So, the bottom line is quite simple. If you are going to use testimonials, and I highly recommend that you do, have you customer write it from their experience. Do not reword or edit it. If you change it, other than not being a true testimonial, you most likely will lose the context you were trying to capture. Then your target market will begin to distrust you and your words. That is bad.
My team and I connect with our market because we have learned how to show them the benefits of working with us. To learn how we accomplished this, go to: http://www.MLMIntegrityMarketing.com/?t=ial and see what we teach our associates.
Tagged with: Attraction marketing • Dillard • Fanale • make money from home • mlm marketing • MLMLeadSystemPro • MLSP • network marketing • Orlewicz • sales ads • testimonials • work at home • work from home
Filed under: Are Testimonials Factual Information or Creative Advertising?
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!






Bill,
Great argument that you bring up here.
Once you started bringing out the examples, yeah, there is a real difference between the two.
What prompted you to write this post?
~ Linus Ruzicka
You’re so right Bill …. I have a hard time believing most testimonials out there….. they just seem a little TOO well written sometimes! lol
Hey Linus,
Thanks for the comments. I stumbled onto this topic after reading several places that many people think all testimonials are fabricated. I disagree that most are fabricated. However, some seem WAY to good to be accurate.
Unfortunately, when people do ads as testimonials, the entire system suffers credibility.
Bill,
Testimonials are great when done right, some people miss use this technique and loose credibility .
Bill,
I’ve always wondered about using testimonials. I have a couple on my blog and I made sure to use their words, no changes.
I want to be able to build credibility, not loose it.
Tamra
Article Marketing
I disagree with only one portion of your post Bill. The part that discusses how people are burnt out on certain types of testimonials. I do not think the VAST MAJORITY of Internet users understand AT ALL what ‘makes them click,’ pun intended.
However, when it came to the part where you laid out the steps of a successful testimonial I learned from you that when it is done RIGHT they can be MORE effective than the normal sales pitch testimonial.
I think what happens is that people using the Internet for a short time are becoming more familiar with marketing online and they (we) start to sense that many people join affiliate programs and have ZERO results and to promote their affiliates they make sales pitch tesimonial vids and this can drive more traffic.
My biggest concern is when watching these testimonials on other affiliate sites how can I tell which people are really getting results and which are not and just telling you how “amazing” the product is; even before they bought it….
Zack
I agree with you, some testimonials seem just too good to be true. The ones that you can tell just come from the heart are the ones that I like best. Thanks for bringing this up, because when I see testimonials I usually just skip over them because you usually do not usually learn anything from them,you just hear mostly a lot of hype.
Thanks,
Kathy Sammons
Kathy Sammons Dot Com
You are so right. That is one reason why I like the video testimonial because there is no real way to alter it and therefor is very believable.
You have made some very good points here.
Thanks
Bob
Unique post Bill,
I agree on your characteristics of a true testimonial vs. a hyped up ad. I think that us veteran marketers are more in tune with a true testimonial verses an ad.
I would say that the general public may not tell the difference for the most part, but as more people are getting online the fine line between ad & testimonial will be more scrutinized.
Great post,
~Bert
Hey Bill,
I agree with Bob…when you use video testimonials, there’s not way that you alter it or embellish anything. You get nothing but a genuine results based social proof.
- Yo
Bill,
Excellent post. I agree with Bert that marketers probably can tell the difference between sincerity and hype. I’ve always questioned the testimonials that end with “J. Smith, Ohio”
John
Google Buzz